The trillion-dollar Obama health care plan increases the odds that US economic recover will be delayed, and that unemployment and inflation will increase.
The main thrust of the Obama plan is to increase taxes on individuals earning more than $250,000 a year, while forcing all but the tiniest businesses to purchase health insurance coverage for employees.
The money raised by these taxes will be transferred as subsidies for those who do not have health insurance — primarily due to low earnings and inability or unwillingness to purchase health insurance without government assistance.
Proposed legislation on Obama care, drafted by House Democrats, covers more than 1,000 pages. Some analysts claim that this huge document contains clauses that will eventually force millions of American to acquire government health insurance.
Typical of Obama reforms, the measure is being rushed through Congress without adequate discussion of consequences, without bi-partisan consensus, and with scant disclosure by the Democrat party that has filibuster-proof control of the US Congress. Most Republicans are expected to vote against the measure.
Increased inflation and unemployment
Most new employment in the United States is created by small and medium-size business — precisely the people that President Obama wants to tax in order to raise funds that will be transferred to poorer, less-productive sectors of the economy.
Businesses being hit by these massive new taxes have only a few ways to respond:
- Reduce the number of employees or delay hiring new employees.
- Pass the costs of higher taxes on to consumers.
- Increase outsourcing of labor costs to offshore suppliers.
- Compensate for rising taxes by reducing wages.
In other words, the immediate impact of Obamacare is likely to be increased unemployment and higher prices — stagflation.
The Obama administration claims that costs of subsidized health insurance will be compensated by undocumented “cost savings” — but these claims are contested by the Congressional Budget Office.
In the next decade, Obamacare is estimated to cost over $1.5 trillion.
Why health costs will continue to rise
Over the last fifty years, costs of health care in the United States have steadily increased faster than other consumer prices.
There are many reasons for the escalating costs of health care, but the two main drivers have been:
- Medical advances: Many life-saving medical procedures are available today that were impossible fifty years ago. Organ transplants are a case in point. The existence of these procedures creates demand. However, many of these procedures are extremely expensive, well beyond the financial capacity of most of the population. In good times, many employers have been willing to give workers free health insurance to cover such costly procedures.
- Employer paid health insurance: The common practice of large businesses providing free health care insurance to employees as a fringe benefit, often written into employment contracts, has created vast inefficiencies in the pricing of medical services, as beneficiaries of health care were disassociated from the normal need to shop for the best service at the lowest price. At the same time, because of the nature of insurance contracts, doctors were paid per procedure rather than for results. The costs of health insurance for individuals not covered by group plans became too high for many to afford.
To these basic structural reasons for escalating health care costs, the Obama plan adds the extra price driver of increasing the size of the market for health services (by offering subsidized coverage to the poor), without a corresponding increase in the number of doctors and nurses.
A missed opportunity
Barrack Obama was elected on a platform calling for change and there is general consensus that reforms of the US health care system are needed.
However, by forcing through a plan that seems almost certain to increase unemployment while spurring inflation, the so-called misery index (inflation plus unemployment) is likely to rise far above the level that prevailed when President Obama took office. Over the last two generations, a rising misery index has portended that the incumbent President will be removed from office by the voters.
This, perhaps, is why President Obama is anxious to pass this highly controversial legislation before his popularity sinks to the point where such legislation will not longer be possible.
Along with mismanaged “spending is stimulus” package and the “cap and trade” legislation, the Obama healthcare plan may seal the fate of this administration.